The $75 Water Bottle and the Lost Suitcase

Customer service and loyalty are built when things go wrong. Discover how communication, empathy, and follow-through can turn problems into lasting trust.

Most businesses like to think they provide good customer service. Most customers would probably disagree.

The reality is that customer service at many businesses stinks. We have become so accustomed to long hold times, unanswered emails, chatbots that can’t answer our questions, and being passed from one person to another that genuinely good customer service can feel almost shocking.

And that creates an enormous opportunity for small businesses.

We tend to think about the impact our businesses create primarily through the products and services we sell. But some of the greatest opportunities to make an impact on a customer happen after something has gone wrong.

I was reminded of that twice recently, in two very different ways.

The water bottle

In June, our family spent a few days at Universal Studios. At some point during one of those days, we managed to leave behind a Yeti water bottle worth about $75.

Not exactly a family crisis, but we liked the bottle, so we filed a lost-item report through the Universal app. The process was simple, and we received confirmation that they were looking for it.

Then something unexpected happened.

A day or two later, Universal contacted us with an update. They hadn’t found the bottle, but they wanted us to know they were still looking. A little while later, another update arrived. Still no bottle, but they hadn’t forgotten about us and would continue the search.

Ultimately, they never found it. And yet I came away impressed by the experience.

Why? Because at every step, Universal made us feel as though our $75 water bottle mattered to them because it mattered to us.

The suitcase

A few weeks later, my wife flew from Toronto to Costa Rica on WestJet. She checked two bags in Toronto. Only one arrived in Costa Rica. She immediately filed a missing-baggage report and received confirmation that WestJet had received the report. And then…

Nothing. For an entire week.

Eventually we called WestJet, waited forever to speak with someone, and were essentially told, “Yes, we’re still looking, but you might want to start preparing a lost bag claim.” To us, it felt like they had given up on finding the bag already.

A few days later, an email arrived from a claims specialist instructing us to complete a detailed form within 21 days, including an itemized list of everything in the suitcase, values, receipts where available, and supporting documentation.

If you’ve ever had the pleasure of reconstructing the entire contents of a suitcase from memory and then trying to establish what everything was worth, you’ll know this task ranks somewhere between doing your taxes and sticking forks in your eyes.

Two more weeks passed without another meaningful update. Even when we crossed the 21-day threshold at which the bag is officially considered lost, there was no proactive communication from the airline. No “We’re sorry we couldn’t find it.” No acknowledgment of what had happened. No sense that there was a human being on the other end who understood how frustrating it was to lose a suitcase containing several thousand dollars’ worth of belongings.

Just silence and a form.

The difference in responses

At Universal we lost something worth $75 and never recovered it. WestJet lost something of ours containing several thousand dollars of contents that, at least so far, hasn’t been recovered either.

In both cases, the ultimate outcome was the same: the item was lost. But our feelings toward the two companies could hardly be more different.

We would happily go back to Universal tomorrow. In fact, the experience probably strengthened my impression of the company because I got to see how its systems work when something goes wrong.

WestJet had the opposite effect. In fact, we recently booked another trip and specifically avoided flying with them, even though that meant paying more elsewhere.

Think about that for a moment. Neither company solved our problem. But one created loyalty while failing, and the other lost loyalty while failing.

Creating lasting IMPACT with your customer service

This is where I think many businesses misunderstand customer service.

They treat it as a cost centre. Something to automate, streamline, outsource, or minimize. The objective becomes handling customer problems as efficiently and inexpensively as possible.

There is obviously nothing wrong with efficiency. But if Impact is one of your business’s priorities (and if you’re a Whole PIE business – it is), you start looking at customer service differently.

A complaint becomes an opportunity to show someone you care. A mistake becomes an opportunity to build trust. A frustrated customer becomes an opportunity to create an advocate.

And you know what’s most interesting? You don’t necessarily have to solve the problem to create that impact.

Universal didn’t find our water bottle. What they did was communicate. They set expectations. They followed up. They showed empathy. Most importantly, they made us feel like somebody cared.

None of that is particularly complicated. Which makes you wonder why it is so rare.

Your competitors are probably giving you an opening

Customer service may be one of the easiest places for a small business to differentiate itself precisely because the bar has become so low.

You probably can’t always offer the lowest price. You may not have the biggest marketing budget, the newest technology, or the broadest product selection. But you can decide that when a customer has a problem, your business is going to respond differently.

That requires more than telling employees to “provide great customer service.” It needs to become part of the way the business operates. Who owns a customer issue? How quickly should someone respond? How often do you update a customer when there is nothing new to report? When should an issue be escalated? How much discretion does an employee have to make something right?

Those are systems questions. And when Impact becomes a priority, the answers change.

Impact eventually finds its way to the scoreboard

In last week’s article, I wrote about Impact as a leading indicator. Customer service is a perfect example of what I meant.

Universal’s emails didn’t create any immediate revenue from us. In fact, searching for a lost water bottle cost them money. WestJet’s lack of communication probably saved some employee time. If you looked only at the immediate transaction, you could make the argument that WestJet’s approach was more “efficient.”

But that’s the wrong scoreboard.

One company strengthened our loyalty. The other lost it. And eventually, those experiences turn into repeat purchases, referrals, reviews, reputation—and revenue.

That’s why Impact isn’t separate from Profit. The way you make people feel today often determines whether they choose you tomorrow.

This Week’s Challenge

At your next leadership meeting, ask:

What happens in our business when something goes wrong for a customer?

Then look at the experience from the customer’s perspective. How easy is it to reach you? Who owns the problem? How often do you communicate? Do you make customers chase you for answers, or do you proactively keep them informed?

Most importantly, ask yourselves:

Does the way we handle problems make customers more likely—or less likely—to choose us again?

Your product or service may be what brings a customer through the door. But what you do when something goes wrong may be what determines whether they ever come back.

Share this Post:

Related Articles

Laptop, notebook, and coffee on a tropical terrace overlooking the Costa Rican coastline, illustrating the freedom to run a business from anywhere.

Own It Like an Expat

Business owner freedom starts with a company that doesn’t need you there every day. Learn how better systems let you run your business from anywhere.

Read More

Get unstuck.

Grab a pen and take the Whole PIE Health Check™ — a quick, free assessment that reveals where your business is strong, where it’s stuck, and what steps will help you get back in control.

Get instant clarity and start building a business that’s Profitable, Impactful, and Enjoyable.

It takes less than 10 minutes!
Scroll to Top
Whole PIE Health Check™ Image

Get unstuck.

Grab a pen and take the Whole PIE Health Check™ — a quick, free assessment that reveals where your business is strong, where it’s stuck, and what steps will help you get back in control.

Get instant clarity and start building a business that’s Profitable, Impactful, and Enjoyable.

It takes less than 10 minutes!