It is rarely the lowest price
Why do you keep going back to the businesses you love?
It is probably not because they are always the cheapest. More often, it is because of how consistently they improve some part of your life.
It might be the contractor who spots a problem before it becomes an emergency, the manufacturer whose products never let you down, or the accountant who replaces confusion with confidence. It might be the restaurant where the food is excellent, but where the real loyalty comes from the way the staff remembers you, welcomes you, and gets the little details right.
Those businesses create something that is difficult for a competitor to copy. They create a positive impact that customers can see, feel, and remember.
That impact earns trust. Trust builds loyalty. And loyalty creates the conditions for sustainable profit.
The danger of managing only the scoreboard
As businesses grow, leaders naturally begin paying closer attention to revenue, margins, cash flow, utilization, and other financial measures. They should. Those numbers tell us whether the business model is working and whether the organization is financially healthy.
But they are still lagging indicators. They tell us what has already happened.
The more useful question is:
What caused those numbers in the first place?
That is one of the central lessons from Moneyball. The Oakland A’s didn’t stop caring about wins. They simply became more disciplined about identifying the activities and statistics that predicted wins before they appeared on the scoreboard.
Business owners need to do the same thing. If customer loyalty, referrals, repeat purchases, employee commitment, and reputation all contribute to long-term profitability, we need to understand what creates those outcomes.
In many businesses, the answer begins with impact.
What customers are actually buying
One of my favourite examples comes from Rubber Duck Car Wash.
Whenever they acquire a new location, one of the very first things they do has nothing to do with soap, equipment, or marketing. They make sure the customer service phone number is impossible to miss. It’s posted at the pay station, inside the automatic wash, in the self-serve bays, beside the vacuums—everywhere a customer might need it.
Why?
Because they know something will eventually go wrong. A payment won’t process. A wash won’t start. A vacuum won’t work. No business is perfect.
The difference is what happens next.
Instead of leaving customers frustrated, wondering who to contact, Rubber Duck makes it incredibly easy to reach a real person, 24 hours a day, seven days a week. The goal isn’t simply to solve problems. It’s to make sure customers feel looked after when problems occur.
That decision costs money. Viewed through the lens of this quarter’s profit and loss statement, it might even look like a poor financial decision. Viewed through the lens of customer loyalty, it’s one of the smartest investments they can make.
Rather than asking, “What’s the cheapest way to provide customer support?” they ask, “How can we make this experience better for our customers?”
That’s an Impact North Star.
Customers may not remember every wash, but they’ll remember how the company responded when they needed help.
An Impact North Star
As a business grows, there are always legitimate financial and operational questions to answer. Should we improve margins? Increase efficiency? Build better systems? Strengthen cash flow? Reduce unnecessary costs?
The answer may be yes to all of them. But those questions should not be considered in isolation from the people the business exists to serve. Before making a significant decision, try asking:
How will this affect the experience of our customers, employees, suppliers, or community?
That does not mean every decision must make everyone happy. Nor does it mean ignoring cost, profitability, or operational realities. It simply means recognizing that the way a decision affects people will eventually find its way back to the scoreboard.
When a business consistently chooses short-term savings at the expense of customer experience, people notice. When employees are treated merely as costs to be managed, they notice too. Over time, trust weakens, loyalty declines, referrals slow, and the financial consequences eventually appear.
Ironically, an excessive focus on profit can weaken the very thing that produces it.
Impact compounds
Businesses that consistently improve people’s lives build advantages that competitors struggle to duplicate. A competitor may copy your pricing, product features, website, or marketing message. It is much harder to copy the trust you’ve built through hundreds of small, positive interactions.
Impact creates trust. Trust strengthens loyalty. Loyalty produces repeat business, referrals, advocacy, and resilience when mistakes inevitably happen.
Impact also affects enjoyment. People generally find more meaning and energy in their work when they can see that their efforts matter to someone. When employees understand how their work improves a customer’s day, solves a meaningful problem, or contributes to something worthwhile, work becomes more than a list of tasks.
That is why Profit, Impact, and Enjoyment are not competing priorities. Properly managed, they reinforce one another.
Measure what creates the result
Most leadership teams already track financial performance. Far fewer consistently measure whether they are creating the impact that will support future financial performance.
Depending on your business, leading indicators of impact might include:
- Customer retention and repeat purchase rates
- Customer referrals
- Online reviews and customer satisfaction scores
- Average response time to customer inquiries
- Percentage of issues resolved on the first contact
- Number of proactive customer check-ins
- Employee engagement and retention
- Employee suggestions for improving the customer experience
The specific measures will vary from business to business. The principle does not.
Do not wait until revenue declines to discover that customer trust has been eroding for months. Identify the behaviours and experiences that create loyalty, then measure whether you are delivering them consistently.
This Week’s Challenge
At your next leadership meeting, ask:
What do our customers value most about the way we serve them, and what evidence do we have that we are delivering it consistently?
Then identify one leading indicator that would help you monitor that impact before it appears in your revenue or profit figures.
Because impact is not something that sits beside business performance. It is one of the forces that creates it.
That’s why, in The Whole PIE System, we don’t treat impact as a nice-to-have; it’s a central focus that we design intentionally. When your business improves people’s lives consistently, profit has a habit of following.



