What If You Get What You Want?

Defining business success means looking beyond revenue and growth. Discover why profit, impact, and enjoyment should shape the business you build.

A lesson from Shoeless Joe.

The character who didn’t make the movie

Most people have seen Field of Dreams. Far fewer have read Shoeless Joe, the W.P. Kinsella novel that inspired it.

I read the book recently and noticed that there are some interesting differences between it and the movie, including a character in the book named Eddie Scissons, who doesn’t appear in the movie. Eddie is an elderly man who has spent much of his life telling people that he was once a professional baseball player—the oldest living Chicago Cub.

Except he wasn’t.

Eddie had dreamed of playing major league baseball, but he never made it. Somewhere along the way, the dream became a story, and the story became something he allowed people to believe about him.

Then Eddie meets Ray Kinsella and finds himself at that magical baseball field in the middle of an Iowa cornfield. And, as only seems possible in Shoeless Joe, Eddie finally gets his chance. His younger self takes the mound as a relief pitcher against the great players of the past.

And he gets rocked.

The dream he had carried with him for virtually his entire life finally comes true—and it’s nothing like he imagined.

Getting what you want

Afterwards, an understandably shaken Eddie says something that stopped me when I first read it:

“I heard somebody say once, success is getting what you want but happiness is wanting what you get.”

Then he adds:

“You saw what happened to me. I got what I wanted, but it wasn’t what I needed to make me happy.”

I’ve been thinking about those lines ever since, because a version of Eddie’s story often plays out with business owners.

We spend years chasing something we’ve defined as success. More revenue. More locations. More employees. A bigger office. A larger valuation. Maybe $1 million in sales, then $5 million, then $10 million.

And there is absolutely nothing wrong with any of those goals. The problem is that we don’t always stop to ask what happens if we actually achieve them.

What does your version of success look like?

Imagine two businesses.

One generates $5 million in revenue, employs 30 people, operates from several locations, and is growing 20% a year. The owner is making good money, but works 60 hours a week, deals constantly with people problems, checks email throughout every vacation, wakes up thinking about cash flow, and can’t remember the last time the business felt fun.

The other business generates $2 million, has a great team of eight people, produces plenty of profit for the owner, allows them to work four days a week, gives them time with their family, and lets them spend most of their working hours doing things they’re actually good at and enjoy.

Which owner is more successful? There isn’t a correct answer.

That’s the point.

The mistake is allowing somebody else—the business community, social media, your competitors, your peer group, or even your younger self—to answer the question for you.

Be careful what you optimize for

Business owners are particularly susceptible to this because almost every conventional measure of business success points in the same direction: more.

More revenue. More customers. More employees. More locations. More market share. More growth.

We rarely see awards for the business owner who deliberately stopped growing at $3 million because they loved the company they’d built. Nobody publishes a list of Canada’s Top 100 Businesses That Are Exactly the Size Their Owners Want Them to Be.

But perhaps they should.

Growth can create Profit and Impact. It can create opportunities for employees and allow you to serve more customers. It can also create complexity, stress, bureaucracy, financial risk, and a business that requires more of its owner rather than less.

If the business becomes objectively more successful while the owner becomes progressively more miserable, something has gone wrong.

Enjoyment isn’t what comes after success

This is one of the reasons Enjoyment sits right up there in the front seat alongside Profit and Impact in The Whole PIE System.

We have a tendency to postpone enjoyment.

Once we get to $5 million, things will settle down.

Once we hire the next three people, I’ll get some time back.

Once we open the second location, I’ll take that vacation.

Once we hit our number, I’ll finally relax.

Then we hit the milestone and move the goalposts. Five million becomes ten. Two locations become five. Twenty employees become fifty. The thing we thought would finally make the business enjoyable simply creates the next thing to chase.

That’s why I don’t believe Enjoyment is something you earn after you’ve created a successful business.

Enjoyment has to be part of how you define success in the first place.

Build the business you actually want

This doesn’t mean you shouldn’t be ambitious. Quite the opposite. It means being more thoughtful about what your ambition is ultimately intended to create.

Maybe you genuinely want to build a $100 million company with hundreds of employees. Fantastic. Maybe you want a highly profitable $2 million business with ten great people and Fridays off. Fantastic. Maybe your goal is to create something that can operate without you so you can start another company. Or perhaps you love being deeply involved in the work and have no desire to step away from it.

Those are all legitimate definitions of success. The important thing is that you choose yours intentionally. Because there may be nothing worse than spending 10 or 20 years climbing the mountain, finally reaching the summit, and realizing you climbed the wrong one.

That’s what I think Eddie Scissons discovered on that magical baseball field. He finally got what he had wanted his entire life.

It just wasn’t what he needed to make him happy.

This Week’s Challenge

Take whatever goal you’re currently pursuing in your business—the revenue target, the expansion, the acquisition, the new location, the bigger team—and imagine you’ve already achieved it. Then ask yourself:

What will my life actually look like when I get there?

What will your average Monday look like? How many hours will you work? What will you spend those hours doing? Who will you spend them with? What will you have more of—and what might you have less of?

And then ask the harder question:

If I get exactly what I want, will I actually want what I get?

Share this Post:

Related Articles

Laptop, notebook, and coffee on a tropical terrace overlooking the Costa Rican coastline, illustrating the freedom to run a business from anywhere.

Own It Like an Expat

Business owner freedom starts with a company that doesn’t need you there every day. Learn how better systems let you run your business from anywhere.

Read More

Get unstuck.

Grab a pen and take the Whole PIE Health Check™ — a quick, free assessment that reveals where your business is strong, where it’s stuck, and what steps will help you get back in control.

Get instant clarity and start building a business that’s Profitable, Impactful, and Enjoyable.

It takes less than 10 minutes!
Scroll to Top
Whole PIE Health Check™ Image

Get unstuck.

Grab a pen and take the Whole PIE Health Check™ — a quick, free assessment that reveals where your business is strong, where it’s stuck, and what steps will help you get back in control.

Get instant clarity and start building a business that’s Profitable, Impactful, and Enjoyable.

It takes less than 10 minutes!